Breaking Bad & Better Call Saul (SPOILERS)
Aug 23, 2022 15:40:09 GMT -8
Post by Incandescence 112 on Aug 23, 2022 15:40:09 GMT -8
Considering that last night's episode had to function as both a finale to Saul and a coda to the Breaking Bad universe as a whole, I thought it did an admirable job. This is a show that managed to accomplish what many spinoffs fail to do - building off the success and capturing the spirit of an earlier series while still functioning as a great show on its own terms. However, just as there is no Better Call Saul without Breaking Bad, there is no downfall of Saul Goodman without the downfall of Walter White, and I quite liked the way these last four episodes captured the tone of latter-day BB while still feeling like a capper for the 59 episodes that preceded them.
I thought Marie's appearance in the crux of the finale was ingenious, as she was always something of a second-tier character on Breaking Bad but still arguably lost more than any of the other original characters by the end. Walt got everything he wanted, Jesse drove off into the sunset, and we're left to assume Skylar and Walt Jr. got the money they needed - but Marie lost her husband and never got any real personal retribution. So it was great to see her confront Saul, the last remaining survivor of Walt's criminal enterprise, and unburden all her emotions on him. It's a nice reminder that, no matter how many seasons we spend watching Jimmy McGill sliding into his inevitable future, he's still not the ultimate victim.
As far as the debate between the two shows go - I'd probably slightly take Breaking Bad over BCS, even if the latter has a clearer overall structure and more established visual palette (building off the already great palette on BB). But it's really close, a testament to just how good the writers have been at crafting this universe and building it in new and thrilling ways.
Agreed. The finale wasn't in the Angel/The Shield-zone of the absolute top-tier of tv finales......but it was still really strong. I liked how it cemented that Saul contains elements of grace and humanism that Breaking Bad, for all its brilliance, lacked. Twas' much less dissonant than Felina's 'let's root for Walter 2 episodes after exposing once for all the rot at his core'.
Ranking time!
1. Breaking Bad S3
2. Better Call Saul S6
3. Breaking Bad S5B
4. Better Call Saul S3
5. Better Call Saul S5
6. Breaking Bad S4
7. Better Call Saul S4
8. Better Call Saul S1
9. Breaking Bad S5A
10. Breaking Bad S1
11. Breaking Bad S2
12. Better Call Saul S2
I would slightly prefer Breaking Bad because I think its crime thriller elements were better integrated into the story. But Better Call Saul is in the tradition of the best tv spin-offs, that don't just repeat what made their predecessor work, but actively expand on that foundation. So claiming BCS as better is a perfectly reasonable position, which I certainly didn't expect when this show was announced. Shows what I know.